We went to Indiana for a New Year's Eve wedding this year. This gave me the chance to stop in and visit my sister's family in Indianapolis- including my two trustworthy cupcake taste testers. We went to the strangest place I've ever been to to get a cupcake- a gas station. No, not a building that used to be a gas station- an actual gas station. The place, Holy Cow Cupcakes, is in an attached side building. It is small and built for to-go orders only. We mulled over our options and settled on a few...chocolate chip cookie dough, decadent chocolate and strawberry with chocolate icing. I was beginning to feel under the weather, so I, in a rare act, only ate half of my chocolate chip cookie dough cupcake. It was very rich and had a generous dollop of cookie dough at the bottom. I've actually attempted these at home before, but Holy Cow's were much better. My niece chose this one too and loved it. My other niece chose the decadent chocolate and didn't speak a word as she ate it. I'm assuming this means good things. Overall, the place is simple with a unique location twist and above average cupcakes. I'll give it 4 sprinkles.
